Project
IntelliJ IDEA
Priority
Major
Type
Feature
Fix versions
10.0 (99.18)
State
Fixed
Assignee
Kirill Kalishev
Subsystem
No subsystem
Affected versions
No Affected versions
Fixed in build
98.379  
  • Created by   Maxim Shafirov
    7 years ago (07 Feb 2005 20:03)
  • Updated by   Anton Kraievoy
    2 months ago (15 Mar 2012 13:34)
  • Jira: IDEABKL-67
    (history, comments)
 
IDEA-57063 Allow Editor window (current tab) to "Float" like tool windows
67
Issue is visible to: All Users
  The issue is visible to the selected user group only
http://www.intellij.net/tracker/idea/viewSCR?publicId=2512
I'd like to be able to click a button or hit a key or select a menu item, and have the current editor "float" in its own window. This would allow me to place it over on a second monitor, or allow me to view the text of two different files side by side. I should be able to float as many editors as I want at time (optimally), but I'd accept even just being able to float one at a time. Whether a floated editor window is "always on top" should be selectable via some widget or menu option.
Comments (38)
 
History
 
Linked Issues (?)
 
CMeyer
  CMeyer
01 Sep 2006 23:09
5 years ago
I would love to see support for floating editor groups.

I have a multi-monitor setup and it's painful to stretch the IDEA window across multiple monitors. It only works if they're aligned and rotated the same way, etc. And then the various splits are still a pain (message window, etc)

Having floating editor tab groups would solve the problem, I believe.
mingfai
  mingfai
27 Oct 2008 23:44
3 years ago
I'd like to add that, ideally, the floating editor should allow splitting as same as normal editor.

for record - in case anyone will reply with useful info
http://www.intellij.net/forums/thread.jspa?messageID=5224670�
George Armhold
  George Armhold
19 Jan 2010 21:39
2 years ago
Yes, please implement this.
Daniel Jimenez
  Daniel Jimenez
10 Apr 2010 00:46
2 years ago
Right now when i want to look at two files side by side i have to use another app. Bummer.
Dmitry Jemerov
  Dmitry Jemerov
10 Apr 2010 12:17
2 years ago
Daniel,

That's not quite true: you can split an editor window and open two different files in different sides. You don't need floating editor tabs for that.
Stephen Friedrich
  Stephen Friedrich
12 Apr 2010 12:56
2 years ago
Dmitry, I guess he meant side-by-side on two different monitors.

Maximizing IDEA itself across the monitors is awkward:
  • the vertical resolution of my two monitors differ, so I can use only the smaller one and waste precious space on the bigger monitor
  • horizontal tool windows, main menu are split in the middle,
  • centered popups like the "Go to Class/file" popup are split in the middle
  • showing/hiding vertical tool windows moves the splitter, so that suddenly part of the first file is visible on the second monitor
  • most importantly for me: I have vertical windows bars (the regular one, plus one from UltraMon on the second monitor), so when I maximize IDEA about 200px are missing in the middle.

Please give IDEA's window system a thorough overhaul!
CMeyer
  CMeyer
12 Apr 2010 19:12
2 years ago
Multi-monitor support is long overdue. Most software engineers I know have dual monitor setups and it's very unfortunate that IDEA still does not support this standard setup.
Daniel Jimenez
  Daniel Jimenez
12 Apr 2010 19:23
2 years ago
Even those who don't have multiple monitors, just one big monitor, have a hard time with IntelliJ. I really don't want IntelliJ taking up my entire screen to just show two file editors.
Sergei Ivanov
  Sergei Ivanov
13 Apr 2010 01:28
2 years ago
Dual monitor set-up is a thing of the past :) Triple and quad monitor set-ups are pretty common for developers in the industry I am in (investment banking). An ability to detach an editor (or a tab group) would be an absolute cracker. For me personally, it would justify another upgrade fee more than, say, a support for yet another framework. Please, please consider including this feature in the roadmap for the next release, especially given the unanimous support among your faithful community.
Wi
  Wi
17 Jun 2010 23:43
23 months ago
Phương Nguyễn Đức
  Phương Nguyễn Đức
17 Jul 2010 16:06
22 months ago
C'mon, 5 years already and you guys making no progress on that?
Behrang Saeedzadeh
  Behrang Saeedzadeh
19 Jul 2010 09:21
22 months ago
Support for multiple monitors/editor windows please!!!
Eric Neilsen
  Eric Neilsen
03 Aug 2010 03:22
21 months ago
Can we get some sort of response from JetBrains. No feedback is the worse kind of feedback that we can have!
Alexey Pegov
  Alexey Pegov
03 Aug 2010 13:51
21 months ago
This issue is planned to be fixed in IDEA X. What kind of feedback do you need?
Eric Neilsen
  Eric Neilsen
03 Aug 2010 19:12
21 months ago
This is music to my ears. That's all the feedback that I needed. I appreciate the quick response.
Mark S.
  Mark S.
11 Aug 2010 19:09
21 months ago
Any chance of getting Tab Groups with this, so that we could float an entire group of tabs(not just a split of tabs).
Eric Neilsen
  Eric Neilsen
11 Aug 2010 19:41
21 months ago
I like that idea, ultimately i think the real power is going to be the ability to drag and drop editors from one screen to another. If you have two "groups of tabs" and could drag individual editors and move them between the two different windows you'd nail everyone expectations. I would pattern it after web browsers like Google Chrome and Firefox. Those browsers work incredibly well w/ multiple monitors.
Dan Kaplan
  Dan Kaplan
11 Aug 2010 20:50
21 months ago
I'd also like this, thanks.
Taras Tielkes
  Taras Tielkes
11 Aug 2010 21:42
21 months ago
What about maximizing specific tool windows on another monitor?
For example, I'd like to "dataflow to this" to always open, maximized, on my second monitor.
Is there a specific issue for such a feature?
Alexey Pegov
  Alexey Pegov
11 Aug 2010 21:50
21 months ago
Taras, you may always check it by creating a new issue and see if it will be closed as duplicate :)
Mark S.
  Mark S.
12 Aug 2010 20:24
21 months ago
Well, depending on how far this is thought out, there is a lot of potential for customization/flexibility here.

A"Window" could hold 1 more or more tab groups(if there is only 1, then the tab group is not show). Windows could be docked or undocked(floating).

Within a window, you could have one or more tab groups. Those could be docked and undocked within a window, so you can arrange them how you want. A tab group could also turned into its own window. A Tab group could be dragged from one window to another.

And, of course, each tab group would contain one or more tabs, which, I think, could be used for more than use open files.

If things such as the debugger, finds, output tabs were treated in a similar matter, you could create a tab group for your debugger windows, then drag that to somewhere else.

This gives you the option of leaving one monitor as your primary coding monitor, and while dragging some of the other windows to another monitor(monitors) and arranging them how you need them, for references, notes, running/ debugging, recent finds/searches, etc.

I know I am over simplifying here, but maybe it deserves some discussion to see if this is a viable option.
Taras Tielkes
  Taras Tielkes
17 Aug 2010 02:31
21 months ago
Alexey - here goes:
IDEA-57472: provide better support for moving toolwindows to second monitor
Wallaby Pouch
  Wallaby Pouch
26 Oct 2010 01:35
19 months ago
Is this coming in IDEA X?
Dmitry Jemerov
  Dmitry Jemerov
26 Oct 2010 08:53
18 months ago
Yes. This feature is being implemented right now.
Wallaby Pouch
  Wallaby Pouch
09 Nov 2010 15:21
18 months ago
Tried the latest EAP, this is pretty cool and very useful. Thanks!
I could not find a keyboard shortcut for this. This would be very helpful, I think.
Maybe even a shortcut to attach a detached tab back to the main window, but I'm not sure about this.
Jason Zaugg
  Jason Zaugg
09 Nov 2010 19:45
18 months ago
The new detachable windows maximize to the size of the screen that the primary window is on, rather than the screen they are moved to.
John Lindquist
  John Lindquist
09 Nov 2010 19:49
18 months ago
@Jason - I'm not seeing that issue on Windows 7.
Jason Zaugg
  Jason Zaugg
09 Nov 2010 19:59
18 months ago
To be clear, it maximises on my second screen, but at the dimensions of the primary screen. Windows XP.
Stephen Friedrich
  Stephen Friedrich
09 Nov 2010 21:04
18 months ago
I also see this bug: I drag a tab to my second screen and the window opens very large and half of it is moved above the screen's boundaries, so that I can't move it (title bar invisible). Windows Vista 64bit, main screen is 1900x1200, secondary is 2048*1152
John Lindquist
  John Lindquist
09 Nov 2010 21:12
18 months ago
Just fyi: on Windows, if the new window is being dropped above the screen boundaries, you can use the Windows "move" shortcuts to bring it back to the top: hit "alt+space", then "m", then "esc".
Chris Miller
  Chris Miller
09 Nov 2010 21:13
18 months ago
I'm seeing the exact same thing as Stephen. I have two monitors side by side both at 1600x1200, Win 7 64 bit. The window's title bar ends up some way above the top of the monitor. If I resize the window using one of the lower/left/right borders, it snaps back down to size and the title bar comes back into view.
Eric Neilsen
  Eric Neilsen
09 Nov 2010 23:10
18 months ago
BTW, I love this new feature. It's going to be a big hit!!! I think you guys built this the right way!!

thanks.
Cristian Vasile Mocanu
  Cristian Vasile Mocanu
12 Nov 2010 13:13
18 months ago
@Stephen & Chris Miller: see IDEA-60964
Cristian Vasile Mocanu
  Cristian Vasile Mocanu
12 Nov 2010 13:16
18 months ago
@Jason Zaugg: same thing here (Windows XP SP3).
The window on the second monitor maximizes to the size that would be correct for the first monitor. For me the difference if because I have my taskbar on the left of the first screen, so when I maximize the window on the second screen, there is a big empty space to its left, of the same size as the taksbar.
George Armhold
  George Armhold
12 Nov 2010 17:36
18 months ago
Just wanted to say that it's GREAT to finally see this feature implemented. A long time coming, but very appreciated. It looks great on Mac now- dragging tabs works beautifully. And the latest EAP is the most stable one I've used in years. Thanks guys!
Anton Kraievoy
  Anton Kraievoy
15 Mar 2012 13:27
2 months ago
So, how do I activate this feature? I don't see any context menu item to float a split or editor tab group in idea 11.
Maxim Shafirov
  Maxim Shafirov
15 Mar 2012 13:31
2 months ago
You just drag that out at file's tab
Anton Kraievoy
  Anton Kraievoy
15 Mar 2012 13:34
2 months ago
Wow. I did a quick heads-up within documentation. Nothing easily searchable came up. I guess we should open/reopen an issue to make this candy more discoverable somehow. Thanks for your help.